Summary the apology is believed to be the most authentic account that has been. Hermogenes stated that with this resolve socrates came before the jury after his adversaries had charged him with not believing in the gods worshipped by the. It is not possible, based on the historical evidence, to say whether platos apology was written before or after xenophons. Each book was the authors literary perceptions and interpretations of the guiltyverdict against the public man socrates. Of socrates to the jury kindle edition by xenophon. It is also possible that socrates defense of himself was even stronger than.
The lengthiest and most famous of xenophons socratic writings, the memorabilia is essentially an apologia defense of socrates, differing from both xenophons apology of socrates to the jury and platos apology mainly in that the apologies present socrates as defending himself before the jury, whereas the former presents xenophons own. The author xenophon presents socratess megalegoria boastful manner of speaking at trial, as a tactic of legal defence against being a corrupt and impious man who is harmful to the athenian polity. Memorabilia xenophon project gutenberg selfpublishing. Platos socrates, on the other hand, is shown with undiminished powers. Greek is a socratic dialogue by xenophon, a student of socrates. His anabasis upcountry march in particular was highly regarded in antiquity and had a strong influence on latin literature. Xenophons work can easily be described as four books within a book. Apology of socrates to the jury shows how socrates conducted himself when he was tried on the capital charge of not believing in the citys gods and corrupting the young. But other accounts of the famous philosopher, including aristophanes hit play the clouds and xenophons socrates defense to the jury, cast the man in a different light. Sep 17, 2016 most of this discussion is indebted to leo strauss short essay, apology of socrates to the jury, in xenophons socrates, south bend. How plato and xenophon created our socrates interprets it, persuading the jury to. Because the athenians did not have an authoritative book comparable to the. Xenophons defense of socrates ancient history encyclopedia. Xenophons conversations of socrates is a great addition to the home library of any lover of socratic philosophy.
Xenophon s apology of socrates download ebook pdf, epub. Click to read more about recollections of socrates, and socrates. Memorabilia is a collection of socratic dialogues by xenophon, a student of socrates. Hermogenes stated that with this resolve socrates came before the jury after his adversaries had charged him with not believing in the gods worshipped by the state and with the introduction of new deities in their stead and with corruption of the young, and replied. Socrates is guilty of rejecting the gods acknowledged by the state and of bringing in strange deities. Click download or read online button to get xenophon s apology of socrates book now. The apology in full apology of socrates to the jury. Socrates then proceeds to interrogate meletus, the man primarily responsible for bringing socrates before the jury. The apology of socrates to the jury is xenophons literary contribution to the many apologia written to explain the trial of socrates 399 bc to the athenian public. Conversations of socrates penguin classics xenophon, robin h. Xenophon has not always been praised for his writing style but he covers the socratic principles thoroughly. It is true that others have written about this, and that all of them have reproduced the loftiness of his words,a fact which proves that his utterance really was of the character intimated.
The lengthiest and most famous of xenophons socratic writings, the memorabilia is essentially an apologia defense of socrates, differing from both xenophons apology of socrates to the jury and platos apology mainly in that the apologies present socrates as defending himself before the jury, whereas the former presents xenophons own defense of socrates, offering edifying examples of socrates conversations and activities along with occasional commentary from xenophon. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. This is the only instance in the apology of the elenchus, or crossexamination, which is so central to most platonic dialogues. Recollections of socrates and socrates defense before the jury. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Librarything is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers all about recollections of socrates, and socrates. He is known for his writings, especially his anabasis, memorobilia and his apology the latter two dealing with socrates and, besides platos writings, the basis for what we know of socrates though ancient sources claim that he wrote more than forty books which were very popular including an. Guthries belief was that plato wrote his account of socrates defense to the jury shortly after socrates trial and death in 399 b.
The lengthiest and most famous of xenophons socratic writings, the memorabilia is essentially an apologia defense of socrates, differing from both xenophons apology of socrates to the jury and platos apology mainly in that the apologies present socrates as defending himself before the jury, whereas the. Xenophon s treatment of socrates in his apology can be explained by a similar polemical motive. Xenophon xenophons defense of socrates ancient origins. The lengthiest and most famous of xenophons socratic writings, the memorabilia is essentially an apologia defense of socrates, differing from both xenophons apology of socrates to the jury and platos apology mainly. Xenophon, greek historian and philosopher whose numerous surviving works are valuable for their depiction of late classical greece. The project gutenberg ebook of the apology, by xenophon this ebook is for the. The first two chapters of book i of this work are especially important, because they explicitly undertake a refutation of the charges made against socrates at his trial. Xenophon 430354 bce was an early disciple of socrates and a contemporary of plato. Each is accompanied by notes and an interpretative essay that will introduce new readers to xenophon and foster further reflection in those familiar with his writing. As danzig interprets it, convincing the jury to condemn him even on unconvincing charges would be a rhetorical challenge worthy of the great. Recollections of socrates and socrates defense before the.
Gabriel danzig, in his recent book apologizing for socrates. The lengthiest and most famous of xenophons socratic writings, the memorabilia is essentially an apologia of defense of socrates, differing from both xenophons apology of socrates to the jury and platos apology mainly in that the apologies present socrates as defending himself before the jury. This book presents translations of three dialogues xenophon devoted to the life and thought of his teacher, socrates. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Xenophon quotes lines 188 to 191, and then skips to lines 198 to 202 from book ii of the iliad. The textual repetitions in the books, indicate that the apology was xenephons original conclusion to the memorabilia. He is best known as the mercenary general who wrote the anabasis, which relates his adventures in leading his men out of persia and back to greece after the disastrous campaign of cyrus the younger. Like plato, xenophon also wrote a speech of defense echoing the presumably impromptu oration that socrates had delivered in front of an athenian jury in the famous trial that sealed the philosophers fate and inflicted enduring shame on athenian democracy. In platos apology, the contrast drawn between the nobility of socrates and the grim verdict of his jurorjudges indicted democracy in the eyes of. Recollection of socrates socrates character and teaching socratic conversations how socrates was a good influence on his friends socrates benefactor and educator of the athenians socrates defense before the jury. His four topics include socrates defense, memoirs of socrates, the dinnerparty, and estate manager. Hermogenes and socrates defense to the jury, that socrates was an old man and for him death was.
I have eschewed footnotes for the sake of a cleaner essay. Apology of socrates it seems to me fitting to hand down to memory, furthermore, how socrates, on being indicted, deliberated on his defence and on his end. His conversation with meletus, however, is a poor example of this method, as it seems more directed. Oct 01, 20 on the other hand, xenophons socrates is displayed as far more overtly suicidal than platos. I have often wondered by what arguments those who drew up the indictment against socrates could persuade the athenians that his life was forfeit to the state. Socrates, xenophon, and plato get any book for free on. After the execution of socrates in 399 bc, a number of his followers wrote dialogues featuring him as the protagonist and. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading apology. The apology by xenophon free ebook project gutenberg.
Recollections of socrates and socrates defense before the jury xenophon, anna s. Memorable things of socrates first edition xenophon. In xenophons socrates defense to the jury, we meet a very different socrates from either platos or. Indeed, much more is made by the xenophonic socrates of the deterioration encountered in old age. Continuing his defense of socrates after his trial and punishment, xenophon focuses on the many different virtues socrates has in common with athenian culture. Unlike plato, whom he accused of making socrates sound too arrogant in his defense. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Jan 18, 2012 xenophon 430354 bce was an early disciple of socrates and a contemporary of plato. On the socrates of xenophon and of plato george anastaplos. Near the end of his last book, xenophon illustrates in a conversation between socrates and, i believe, hippias or might be euthydemus since he was in plenty of dialogues throughout. The principal event in the apology of socrates to the jury is socratess rejection of an attack upon his character, by anytus. The socrates of aristophanes is a somewhat silly sophist in fact, socrates later referred to this play as his first trial in athens.
Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. While plato acknowledges that socrates failed in conventional terms, and develops an alternative framework for evaluating success and failure, xenophon makes the more outrageous claim that socrates was a success in conventional terms. In conversations of socrates xenophon writes extensively on the philosophical thought of the master in a forthright and simple manner. Xenophon framed socrates defense, which both men admit was not prepared at all, not as failure to effectively argue his side, but as striving for death even in the light of unconvincing charges. It is almost as if he is courting death at this time. The apology of socrates to the jury by xenophon of athens, is a socratic dialogue about the. Very few extant works remain on the life of socrates. Xenophon framed socrates defense, which both men admit was not. Platos other dialogs and also with the account given in xenophons memorabilia.
163 1193 1028 1574 775 453 754 1599 860 332 907 793 599 1013 863 1272 51 414 1534 624 430 1315 1012 792 1462 1404 904 729 407 1053 739